Wisconsin employs a modified comparative negligence system, which can significantly impact the outcome of a personal injury case. If an injured person is found to be 51% or more at fault for an accident, they can’t recover any damages.
If they’re 50% or less at fault, they can still collect compensation, just reduced by their percentage of blame.
This 51 percent rule creates a critical threshold. It really determines whether crash victims walk away with nothing or get substantial compensation.
The stakes are huge for accident victims in Milwaukee and across Wisconsin. Someone who suffers $100,000 in damages but is 30% at fault will recover $70,000.
But if they’re found 51% at fault, they get nothing—even with the same injuries. Wisconsin’s comparative negligence law can result in small differences in fault percentages being worth thousands of dollars.
How do you calculate those fault percentages? Who decides, and what strategies actually work? The answers can mean the difference between financial recovery and devastating loss.
The law includes specific rules for joint liability, exceptions, and tactical moves that most people only learn when they’re already in the thick of it.
Milwaukee crash victims face unique headaches under Wisconsin’s modified comparative negligence system. That 51% threshold determines whether victims receive compensation at all.
Strict time limits add pressure for anyone seeking damages. If you wait too long, you might lose your shot entirely.
The 51% rule creates a hard cutoff for Milwaukee accident victims. If the injured party is 51% or more at fault for their own injury, they can’t recover any damages.
This threshold makes fault determination everything. If you’re found 50% at fault, you get reduced compensation. At 51%, you get nothing.
Compensation Formula:
Milwaukee intersection accidents often spark arguments over fault percentages. Weather, traffic lights, and visibility issues can shift blame back and forth.
Insurance companies attempt to push victims over the 51% threshold to avoid paying claims. The rule shapes settlement negotiations, too.
Defense attorneys use the 51% bar to pressure victims into taking less. They argue that even small mistakes by the victim contributed a lot to the crash.
Wisconsin gives you three years to file a personal injury lawsuit from a motor vehicle accident. The clock starts on the accident date—not when you discover your injuries.
This deadline puts Milwaukee crash victims on the clock. Evidence can disappear, witnesses may forget, and medical records become increasingly difficult to track down over time.
Critical Timeline Factors:
Some exceptions stretch the deadline. Victims under 18 have until their 21st birthday or three years from the accident, whichever is later.
If your case involves a government entity, you need to give notice within 120 days. No wiggle room there.
The statute interacts with the 51% rule during case prep. Attorneys need time to gather evidence and build a strong argument for favorable fault allocation.
Milwaukee’s traffic patterns create their own brand of fault scenarios under the comparative negligence statute. Construction zones, one-way streets, and heavy pedestrian traffic make things tricky.
Insurance adjusters who know Milwaukee intersections often assign predictable fault splits. Left-turn accidents at places like North Avenue and Water Street usually go a certain way.
Common Milwaukee Fault Scenarios:
Milwaukee lawyers who know comparative negligence understand these local patterns. They know which intersections are trouble and adjust their strategies.
Local courts adhere to the 51% rule but also consider Milwaukee-specific factors. Factors such as snow removal timing, construction signage, and traffic signals can influence fault determinations.
Understanding Wisconsin’s 51% rule is critical—don’t risk losing your recovery. Third Coast Lawyers builds strong cases with evidence and strategy. Reach out today for your free case review.
If you’re ready to get started, call us now!
Wisconsin’s comparative negligence statute sets up a modified system. Injured parties can recover damages even if they’re partly at fault.
The law sets a 51% threshold. That decides whether you can recover at all and how much your compensation gets reduced.
Wisconsin’s comparative negligence law runs on four main ideas. These shape how much money injured people can recover.
The statute lets injured people collect damages even when they share blame. That’s way different from the old rules that blocked all recovery if you were even a little at fault.
Court awards get reduced by the injured person’s percentage of fault. If you’re 20% at fault, your compensation drops by 20%.
Wisconsin uses a “51% rule” for modified comparative negligence. If you’re 51% or more responsible, you get nothing.
Anyone less than 51% at fault only pays their share. No one pays more than their fair portion.
Wisconsin Statutes Section 895.045 covers all comparative negligence claims in the state. You’ll find it in Chapter 895, which deals with damages and liability.
The law goes by “Contributory negligence” in the Wisconsin statutes. However, it actually establishes a comparative negligence system.
The 2024 version maintains the 51% threshold at the forefront. Under Wisconsin law, shared fault is considered instead of blocking claims outright.
Courts must apply this statute in all negligence cases, including personal injury, property damage, and wrongful death. The law supersedes old standard law rules that previously barred recovery for any fault at all.
Wisconsin courts consider specific factors when assigning fault percentages to each party in an accident or injury.
The negligence of the plaintiff is measured separately against each person found causally negligent. Courts judge each person’s actions on their own.
Judges and juries only assign fault to parties whose negligence actually caused harm. There needs to be a direct link to the injuries or damages.
Courts weigh the seriousness and impact of each party’s negligent actions. More reckless or dangerous behavior usually gets a higher fault percentage.
Testimony, accident reports, expert opinions, and physical evidence all play a role. Courts examine all aspects surrounding the incident.
If you’re ready to get started, call us now!
Wisconsin’s joint and several liability rules only kick in when defendants are 51% or more at fault. Concerted action can make multiple parties fully responsible, even if their individual fault percentages are lower.
Plaintiffs can recover full damages from any defendant who is 51 percent or more causally negligent. That means if one defendant carries most of the blame, they’re on the hook for the entire award.
The 51% threshold draws a clear line. Defendants below 51% only pay their proportional share.
Say three defendants have fault percentages of 60%, 25%, and 15%. The plaintiff can collect the full $100,000 judgment from the 60% defendant alone.
The other two would only be liable for their specific portions if sued separately. This rule protects plaintiffs when one major defendant has deep pockets and others can’t pay.
Wisconsin changed its common law in 1995 to limit joint and several liability to cases where a defendant crosses the 51% line.
If a defendant pays more than their share, they can seek reimbursement from the others.
Concerted action liability stands out as an exception—defendants can end up jointly and severally liable, no matter how small their individual fault might be. If a few people work together on a plan and someone gets hurt, this rule kicks in.
Wisconsin courts usually spot concerted action when defendants act under a shared plan. Think: racing drivers, people teaming up for a coordinated attack, or folks agreeing to do something dangerous together.
If you join in, even a little, you could be on the hook for all the damages. The law basically says, “If you’re in, you’re all in,” and treats everyone as equally responsible.
Key concerted action elements:
Professional malpractice and products liability cases sometimes follow different joint and several liability rules. Certain statutory exceptions can override the usual 51% rule in these situations.
If a defendant pays more than their fair share of damages, they can file contribution claims against other responsible parties. This helps ensure that one defendant is not unfairly burdened with the entire financial responsibility when multiple parties contributed to the harm.
In Wisconsin, contribution claims between defendants depend on each party’s percentage of fault.
The defendant who paid too much can attempt to recover the excess amount from co-defendants, up to the portion each is actually responsible for.
Contribution calculation example:
There are deadlines for filing contribution claims. If defendants miss these time limits, they lose the chance to recover from co-defendants.
Settlement agreements can complicate things. Defendants who settle early might lower their risk of facing contribution claims from others who don’t pay.
Third Coast Lawyers helps Milwaukee accident victims secure fair compensation under Wisconsin’s comparative negligence law. Free consultations, no fees unless you win—contact us now to schedule your case review.
What does Wisconsin’s 51% comparative negligence law mean?
It means that if you are 51% or more at fault for an accident, you cannot recover any damages. If you are 50% or less at fault, your compensation is reduced by your fault percentage.
Can I still recover damages if I was partly at fault?
Yes. If your share of fault is less than 51%, you can still recover damages, reduced by your fault percentage. For example, if you are 25% at fault, you can still receive 75% of your damages.
Who decides the percentage of fault in Wisconsin accidents?
A jury or judge determines fault percentages based on evidence like police reports, witness testimony, accident reconstruction, and medical records.
What happens if one defendant is 51% or more at fault?
Under Wisconsin law, a defendant who is 51% or more at fault may be held jointly and severally liable, meaning the plaintiff can collect the full damages from that defendant.
Is 50% fault the same as 51% fault?
No. At 50% fault, you may still recover half of your damages. At 51% or more, you are completely barred from recovery.
How long do I have to file a claim under Wisconsin’s negligence law?
You typically have three years from the date of the accident to file a personal injury lawsuit in Wisconsin. Shorter deadlines may apply for cases involving government vehicles.
Why should I hire a lawyer for a comparative negligence case?
Insurance companies often argue that victims share more fault than they do. A lawyer helps gather evidence, present strong arguments, and ensure you receive the maximum possible recovery.
Third Coast Lawyers empower clients through education, experience, and advocacy — helping injury victims understand their rights and pursue the legal remedies they deserve.
© Copyright 2025 | Third Coast Lawyers LLC. All rights Reserved. Sitemap | Privacy Policy
